** Originally reviewed for Penwick Chronicles **
I loved the new ideas of supernatural creatures and how they fit into our world. I really wanted to like this book but in the end the new ideas weren't enough. The book is told from two different points of view and for most of the book I couldn't figure out why Caleb was so important. I wish the two viewpoints would have connected sooner. At times I felt like I was reading two different stories in one book. I didn't find Kalista's relationship with Tristan to be believable at all. Her feelings changed way too fast. I loved the science lesson about the water crystals I found that section fascinating especially after I searched it on the internet and found out it was all based on real research.